The Descriptive Parts of Speech -

Response to the prompt from Rosemary at Poets&Storytellers United

This poem, by Wilfred Owen, is out of copyright so I can quote it in full: -

Owen was an infantry officer in the First World War.  His subject, in his own words, was 'war, and the pity of war.'  He was killed on the  Western Front a few days before the 11/11/1918 Armistice.  He was highly regarded by the men under his command.

The poem is 'about' a single one of the tens of thousands of battlefield corpses.

Futility 

Move him into the Sun— 

Gently its touch awoke him once, 

At home, whispering of fields half-sown. 

Always it woke him, even in France, 

Until this morning and this snow. 

If anything might rouse him now 

The kind old sun will know. 

Think how it wakes the seeds— 

Woke once the clays of a cold star.

Are limbs, so dear-achieved, are sides 

Full-nerved, still warm, too hard to stir? 

Was it for this the clay grew tall? 

—O what made fatuous sunbeams toil 

To break earth's sleep at all?

I have hilited Owen's (twelve) adjectives and adverbs.   

Is Owen's use of the 'Descriptive Parts of Speech' . . excessive/sparing/just right?

Does the poem 'describe the scene'?  Or 'evoke the scene in your imagination'?  Are any of his 'D.P.O.S' clichés?

Fans of the 'Descriptive Parts Of Speech' can perhaps suggest how a few more/a lot more would improve the mood/sentiments/pity in the poem?

Why no comma between 'kind' and 'old' in line 7?

Is the metaphor in lines 2 and 3 made wonky by 'whispering'? Suggest an improvement.  (Is this question relevant, Lucy?)

What about the half-rhymes?  Skilful?  Forced? Didn't really notice?

What do you make of the 'fatuous' sunbeams in the next last line?  What job does 'fatuous' do in the context?  Can you suggest a better D.P.O.S? 

********

Stephen King (great writer if you like his sort of thing) said 'The road to Hell is paved with adverbs.'

My first writing coach said 'Be sure your adverb is not a crutch for a limping verb'

Ezra Pound said 'If you can't write with just the substantives (he meant nouns, verbs, pronouns, prepositions and the logical connectives) you can't write! (OUCH!)

A somewhat different approach to the prompt on Poets & Storytellers #102 suggested by Rosemary.

Friday Writing #93

Lost

You gave me roses, laughter and a ring.

Gold dulls. Fragrances fade. Some day, who knows,

the sorrows you left with me will cease to sting.

This week's prompt from Rosemary  - to write about scents - could go many ways. 

I  went the short way . . .

Imagine -

- going deaf.  Now imagine a composer going deaf at the height of his creative power.  This was Ludwig van Beethoven's fate.  By his early thirties he had lost his hearing completely.  After his death his "Heiligenstadt Testament," in which he describes the onset of his deafness and the social isolation it resulted in, was discovered amongst his papers.

But his affliction didn't stop him!  All his symphonies after the 5th, his 5th. Piano Concerto 'The Emperor", the string quartets, were all composed when he was completely deaf.

I have posted this poem in response to the Poets&Storyellers United suggestion that we write about 'Triumph and Disaster."  Beethoven surely triumphed over both disaster and despair.

The musical references in the poem relate to his piano sonata in D Minor (Op31, No2) to which people who maybe should know better have given the nickname 'The Tempest."  The first page of the score is shown in my left sidebar.

Affliction

"Speak louder, shout, for I am deaf."

They heard the windswept tremolos in awe,

their ebb and flo, as waves crash on the strand,

an undertow to anger, loss, to pain, 

his jagged figures challenging despair.

"Speak louder, shout, for I am. Deaf."

They asked “What does your new sonata mean?”

Can you imagine the withering look this brought?

How he might snort and shake his untidy locks?

“Go to your Shakespeare! Read ‘Tempest’” he scoffed.

"Speak louder, shout, for I. Am. Deaf."

‘Tempest’ The nickname stuck!  At least it’s more

appropriate than “Moonlight”  No moonbeams

light the rage of that finale, never mind

triplets that lap the shore of Lake Lucerne.

Go to “The Tempest”, then. So. Does he mean

his new work is 'rough magic'? Or perhaps

the lilting rondo is Miranda’s dance

at her wedding to noble Ferdinand?

For sure in the wintry gales we hear

a ship grind on the reef, splinter in shards

and sink to the deeps on bass arpeggios

I prefer “Our revels now are ended.”

Here he admits the best of life is over.

From now on all that seems sublime, heroic,

wild, will play out only in his unkempt head,

where still he hears what his ear no longer can,

with courage that proves the artist and the man.

"Speak louder. Shout, for I am DEAF."

Friday Writings #91

 Street Scene

The passers-by scarcely spare us a glance -

just a young couple, leaning on each other

hand-in-hand, pausing before shop windows,

choosing - for all they know - our bottom drawers.

They do not feel the pressure from his hand,

his fingers tracing, wordless in my palm,

easily decoded messages,

romancing me - this in the pubic street!

What's there to holding hands that's indiscreet?

Nothing.  But could they hear my churning heart

they'd look the other way, they would, and sigh

and wonder what became of hands they held,

of years that sped away and lovers too.

Well then, I think they should reminded be . . .

I seize his shoulders, turn him to me, cry

'How long since last you kissed me? Come on then!'

Now they'll take notice - me on tip-toes, he,

his hands tucked in my coat, drawing me close,

but whispering 'what on earth's come over you?

People are staring!'  That was the idea.

I murmur, 'wait till I get you home . . .' And now

they nudge each other, 'See those two!  So sweet.'

May I join in your Friday Writings?   My poem was inspired by the 'muscle memory' prompt.  The muscles went AWOL during the writing, but something of the memory remains.